everything here is interactive: we set the defaults, you can change them. think a product has a different finish than the one shown? change it! want to track where you keep things ( location) or thoughts about the best lip brush or lip primer for this lipstick, or if you apply it directly from the tube? write yourself a personal collection note, or tell the world in a review.

we’ve placed have / want / had icons everywhere you see a product, either on a picture, in a list (like on the brand or category pages), as well as at the top of individual product pages like this one for Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour - 32 Wine & Dine by Clinique. add products to your makeup collection wherever you see these icons. once there, you can sort by category, have/want/have, or even build your own custom kits for further organizing.



8.0 *
- . - critics
- . - users
average rating based on
less then fifty reviews
* review details for product, not specific to this shade

Application - how did this product apply?
glides tugs
Moisturizing - how moisturizing is this product?
hydrating drying
Long-Wearing - how long-wearing is this product?
stays all day disappears quickly
Colour - does this product shift, or is it true to the pan/box/tube?
true to colour color shifter
Pigmentation - how pigmented is this product?
opaque sheer
Luster - how lustrous is this product?
glossy matte
Buildable - how buildable(ability to build up more color) is this product?
builds easily hard to build
Feathering - how feathering is this product?
stays put feathers or bleeds
Texture - how is the texture of this product?
smooth gritty
Value - how would you rate the value of this product overall?
overdelivered underdelivered

Prefer prose? A snappy summary of reviews so far: Looking at review rankings for the application category an average of four suggests users & critics when asked "how did this product apply?" usually suggest glides. In the colour category the current five suggests responses to "does this product shift, or is it true to the pan/box/tube?" tended towards true to colour. On the pigmentation category an average total of four is a sign that replies to "how pigmented is this product?" are slightly towards opaque. Reviewing the luster category a rating of four suggests reviewers evaluating "how lustrous is this product?" somewhat favor glossy. Feedback for the texture category the rating of four indicates in response to the "how is the texture of this product?" generally indicate smooth.

at blushgarden, we think differently about reading and writing beauty product reviews. we believe product reviews should provide you with detailed information, let the writer quickly and easily share their thoughts, and be a fun experience for all. to achieve this, we provide a ratings scale for distinct criteria, alongside traditional written comments. this format gives reviewers a way to provide an in-depth review of the same specific aspects of a product, allowing you zero in on the criteria that are most important to you.

without the need for long-form written text, everyone saves time. don’t let us discourage you from waxing poetic if you are so inclined, some people are gifted writers and should share if they want to. we just want to encourage and provide great reviews without that particular barrier to entry.

as an example, one rating criteria for lipsticks is luster. luster ranges from matte to glossy. Matte might be a desired quality for you, while glossy might be desired for someone else. there isn’t a right answer, only your opinion.

an added benefit to the scales is quickly seeing how a product might perform. you can identify that a product is rated highly for luster without reading a lot of text. easily compare and evaluate similar products based on identical criteria. apples to apples, if you will.

we would honestly love to hear your feedback, if you have an idea for a new rating criteria, let us know! post in the feedback forum, or send us an email to .

join the community

potentially helpful related reviews
not for this shade
Clinique Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour - 01 Barely

It has great pigmentation and feels hydrating and nourishing on the lips. read the full review

Shimmering Highlights @ Sarah
Clinique Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour - 26 Vintage

The pigmentation is semi-sheer but even and the finish has a high-sheen, translucent feel. read the full review

The Happy Sloths @ Jasmine
Clinique Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour - 46 Rumour Has It

my new best friends. Long lasting (up to 9hrs), hydrating, smoother read the full review


not a review but perhaps helpful - here is a description from the source: No parabens. No phthalates. No fragrance. Allergy tested.

other popular suggestions: Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour 46 Rumour Has It Dramatically Different Lipstick Shaping Lip Colour 04 Canoodle